top of page
IMG_9328.jpeg
Menu


Cakes
Southern style cakes - with just a dash of whimsy! Starred offerings are our 2025 Specialty Flavors.


White Almond Wedding Cake
A decadent, soft, classic wedding flavor with a bright white color and subtle hint of almond. Our Southern twist on classic wedding cake.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


White Cake with Berries
Our classic Southern white almond cake, baked with chopped raspberries, blueberries, blackberries and strawberries.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Confetti Cake
Classic vanilla flavor with pops of rainbow colored sprinkles.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Strawberry Cake
An incredibly moist cake full of fresh, pureed strawberries - making it a gorgeous pink color!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Lemon Cake
A lovely white cake full of freshly zested lemon.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Pink Champagne Cake
A light, airy, white cake made with high-quality rosé champagne. The perfect cake for a toast!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Chocolate Cake
A rich, decadent chocolate flavor - extra dark and delicious. A favorite for the groom!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Red Velvet Cake
A creamy milk chocolate cake with a stunning red color, and that classic Southern tanginess we all love.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Hummingbird Cake
A warm spice cake made with bananas, pineapple and pecans - a Southern classic.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Spice Cake
Our twist on a Southern spice cake, with a perfect blend of spice and citrus.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


White Vanilla Bean Cake
A fluffy white cake full of fresh vanilla beans - bursting with rich flavor.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Carrot Cake
A classic spice cake full of carrots, pecans and raisins - a Southern favorite!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


White Chocolate Raspberry Cake
A pillowy white chocolate cake studded with fresh raspberries - the perfect blend of tart and sweet.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Key Lime Cake
Fresh, tart, and creamy - a cake version of our favorite Floridian Key Lime Pie!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Banana Cake
A soft, buttery banana cake with hints of cinnamon.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Florida Sunshine Cake
A refreshing white cake with a hint of citrus, orange zest, and a secret ingredient - it's not the same without our blush strawberry filling!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Lemon Blueberry Cake
Our classic lemon recipe, bursting with bright blueberries!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Tuxedo Cake
Layers of dark chocolate and white cakes with vanilla and fudge buttercreams - the best of both worlds, all in one slice!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


Churro Cake
A sweet cinnamon sugar cake with a chocolate sauce drizzle between the layers - reminiscent of one of our favorite treats! It pairs perfectly with our cinnamon buttercream.
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200


White Whiskey Cake
A soft white cake with warm vanilla bean and notes of a luxurious, high-quality whiskey - we love to pair this cake with our custom Bourbon Caramel Buttercream. Perfect for the tasteful groom!
6 inch
$100

8 inch
$150

10 inch
$200



Buttercreams
Choose to fill your cake with any of our delicious fillings! Fillings add $.50 per serving to you cake flavor choice.


Jessica's Wedding Buttercream
The buttercream we are known for - a classic American style with the perfect blend of vanilla and almond flavor.


Mixed Berry Filling
Pureed raspberries, strawberries, blueberries and blackberries into our classic buttercream. A lovely choice with pink champagne and white cake with berries.


Peanut Butter Buttercream
Inspired by Jessica's family peanut butter fudge recipe, but whipped to perfection. Delicious with our chocolate cake.


Salted Caramel Buttercream
A whipped buttercream full of yummy caramel and a little extra salt. Perfectly paired with our Southern yellow butter cake or spice cake.


Cream Cheese Buttercream
A sweet, tangy compliment to our Red Velvet, Carrot and Strawberry cakes!


Chocolate Fudge Buttercream
A deep, dark chocolate flavor - a wonderful choice to make our chocolate cake so much more decadent.


Coffee Milk Buttercream
Our classic American buttercream whipped up with dark espresso cream - giving it the perfect creamy coffee flavor. Perfect with our chocolate cake!


Vanilla Bean Buttercream
Classic American buttercream with rich Madagascar vanilla bean throughout.


Blush Strawberry Buttercream
A classic buttercream with a fresh strawberry base, swirled with jam, giving it the most perfect blush pink color.


Cinnamon Buttercream
A warm, spicy cinnamon sugar flavor with hints of vanilla - wonderful with Churro or Spice cakes!



Tastings
subject to availability.


Custom Tasting Box
4 mini cakes, any flavor, with filling of your choice. Each mini cake serves 4-6. Available for any order meeting the $500 minimum.
200


Bakers Choice Tasting Box
4-5 bakers choice sample box - this is typically flavors we have fresh for the week. The fee for this box is applied toward your invoice total, if you choose to book with us.
60


Complimentary Tasting Box
4-5 cake samples, bakers choice, boxed and ready to go! Available for any order meeting the $500 minimum that has already paid a retainer.



Confections



Cake Truffles
Cake truffles are offered in sets of 24, and can be any cake flavor from our menu with a hard shell or rolled in cocoa, coconut, or powdered sugar.
120


Cake Shooters
Cake shooters are available in sets of 24, and in any flavor combination from our menu, or in custom flavor combos! They are served in hand-held cup with a mini spoon.
192


Brownies
A thick, gooey, decadent bar of chocolate perfection - chocked full of semi-sweet chocolate chips, with the expected crinkly crust. A chocolate lover's dream! Sold per dozen.
48


Red Velvet Bars
A gooey, soft, red velvet base with a cream cheese buttercream topping - a favorite from our Christmas sale, so we decided to keep it! Sold per dozen.
48


Chess Cake Bars
A classic gooey butter bar - straight from our Alabama Christmas celebrations! Sold per dozen.
48


Cupcakes
Available in any cake flavor combo from our menu, sold per dozen.
48

Sweetly Sisters is based out of Jessica and Michelle's homes in Santa Rosa Beach, Florida, as two separate legal, insured Cottage Food Operations not subject to Florida Food Safety regulations. 

unnamed-2.png
bottom of page